Dealer vs Locksmith Key Fob Chooser
Tell us what happened to your key, what kind of key it is and how fast you need it. The chooser compares the dealer, a locksmith and doing it yourself, and recommends the best route.
Find the best route for your key
Dealer, locksmith or DIYHow to use the chooser
- Say what you need. A spare, a replacement for lost keys, or a fix for a fob that stopped working.
- Choose the key type. Smart keys cost more and are harder to program than basic keys.
- Describe the vehicle. New and European models narrow your options.
- Set the urgency. Needing it today rules out waiting for shipping.
- Compare the three routes. The recommended row is highlighted, with typical costs for each.
For most mainstream cars, an automotive locksmith is cheaper and faster than a dealer for key fob replacement, often by 25 to 40 percent, and many will come to you. The dealer is the better choice for luxury and European brands, very new models and cars still covered by a key warranty. If the fob has only stopped working or the case is broken, try a new battery or a replacement shell first.
There is no single right answer to the dealer or locksmith question. It depends on what went wrong, what you drive and how quickly you need to be back on the road. The chooser above weighs those factors and points you to the route that usually works out best.
Dealer vs Locksmith at a Glance
| Dealer | Automotive locksmith | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical cost, smart key | $315 to $700 | $230 to $530 |
| Typical cost, basic key | $160 to $450 | $110 to $340 |
| Speed | Same day if in stock, otherwise a few days | Often same day |
| Comes to you | Rarely | Often |
| Coverage | Every model of that brand | Most popular makes, fewer new or European models |
| Parts | Original | Original or aftermarket |
| All keys lost | Car usually towed in | Done at the car |
For a detailed price estimate by key type, use the key fob replacement cost calculator.
When the Dealer Is the Better Choice
- Luxury and European brands. Many of their keys are ordered pre-coded by VIN and can only be added with factory systems.
- Brand-new models. Aftermarket programming tools often take a year or more to support a new generation.
- Warranty or recall work. If the key or the car’s receiver is faulty, the dealer may cover it.
- You want an original part. Dealers supply the maker’s own key.
When a Locksmith Is the Better Choice
- All keys are lost. A mobile locksmith works at the car, which saves a tow.
- You need it today. Many offer same-day and after-hours service.
- Mainstream makes. Toyota, Honda, Ford, GM, Nissan, Hyundai, Kia and Chrysler group cars are well covered.
- Price matters most. Lower overheads and aftermarket parts keep the bill down.
Not every locksmith works on cars. Look for an automotive specialist and check reviews. See can a locksmith fix a key fob for what they can and cannot do.
When You Can Do It Yourself
Three jobs are well within reach for most owners:
- Battery replacement. The fix for most fobs that stop working. Find the right cell with the key fob battery finder.
- Shell replacement. A cracked case or worn buttons do not need a new key.
- Owner programming. Possible on some older and domestic models. Check yours with the programming cost calculator.
How to Avoid Overpaying
Get two all-in quotes by phone, with your year, make, model and key type. Ask whether programming is included, whether there is a call-out fee and whether your existing keys will be reprogrammed at the same visit. Be wary of a very low phone quote that rises on arrival. If a fob can be repaired, that is usually cheaper than a new key, as covered in key fob repair cost.
Frequently Asked Questions
Usually, yes. For mainstream cars a locksmith is often 25 to 40 percent cheaper and can come to you. Dealers cost more but cover every model of their brand.
No. Most automotive locksmiths cover popular makes well, but some new models and many European luxury cars need dealer equipment.
Not for most mainstream cars. A mobile automotive locksmith can usually cut and program a new key at the car. Some luxury and European models do require the dealer.
Some will, for their normal programming fee, but many refuse or offer no guarantee if the key fails to program. Ask before you buy the fob.
Photo ID, proof of ownership such as the registration or title, and the VIN. Bring any working keys too, since some cars reprogram all keys at once.
